Crooked Creek Steelhead Fishing: Pennsylvania State

Crooked Creek steelhead fishing is great for silver fall steelhead steelhead like this one.
Steelhead fishing on Crooked Creek is great in the fall when the river gets enough rain to bring in lots a silver steelhead like this one.

If you are planning to do some Crooked Creek steelhead fishing, this guide can help you find your way around. I will offer tips on access, seasonal info, and the best methods and baits to try.

Crooked Creek Steelhead Fishing

Crooked Creek steelhead fishing is great for winter steelhead like this one
Steelhead fishing on Crooked Creek in the winter when the water is high is great for winter steelhead like this one.

Crooked Creek is situated just east of Holliday Road where it meets Lake Erie, north of Camp Fitch, this stream offers an abundance of opportunities for anglers.

Crooked Creek stretches across Route 215, US Route 20, and Route 5, providing multiple access points for fishing enthusiasts.

As one of the largest creeks in Steelhead Alley, it boasts excellent steelhead fishing and more. The creek extends for miles, offering various locations to cast your line. Steelhead can be found from fall through winter and sometimes even into spring, making it an ideal spot for year-round fishing.

One of the advantages of Crooked Creek is the availability of fishable sections with reasonable flows and water levels. However, it’s important to note that the creek does pass through some farmlands, which can cause discoloration after periods of rain and snow melt.

Despite this, Crooked Creek doesn’t receive as much fishing pressure as nearby Elk Creek and Walnut Creek, making it a tranquil haven for those seeking peace and quiet.

In the spring, Crooked Creek’s lower reaches, from the mouth to Glosky Road off Lexington Road, are stocked with trout. You can fish freely at the mouth up to the designated nursery waters, which are clearly signposted and run through Camp Fitch and up to the first bridge at Ables Road.

The water of Crooked Creek is typically very clear but can become discolored and is usually the first stream to dirty and usually one of the last to clear up after heavy rains or snowfall.

The Fishing Seasons Of Crooked Creek

Crooked Creek steelhead fishing is great for nice spring steelhead like this one.
Crooked Creek fishing can be hit and miss. The key is to be there after rains and snow melt in the fall and spring.

Fall, winter, and spring are when you will find steelhead in Crooked Creek.

Fall Steelhead Fishing On Crooked Creek

Fishing in the fall season is one of the most best times for steelhead fishing.

In Crooked Creek, some great opportunities to catch big steelhead start in October following big cool rains. More and bigger fish will arrive in November and early December. Runs will be sporadic, but after the rains raise river levels, runs of fresh steelhead can occur, right up until the river freezes over.

Winter Steelhead Fishing On Crooked Creek

The winter season can still be a great time for anglers fishing for Steelhead, but you need to be aware of how the fish react to the icy temperature.

The colder the water, the less likely the Steelhead are to bite, but it isn’t completely impossible if you know how to handle fishing for Steelhead on Crooked Creek during the winter.

As the creek gets colder, the fish tend to move into slower-moving pockets and pools where warmer water collects.

If you’re fishing Crooked Creek in the winter, be aware that the trout’s metabolism slows down considerably due to the cold air and colder water. This means they will not feed as often or as heavily until it warms up, so an angler has to be prepared.

The name of the game for winter steelhead is slow and deep. Slower fishing methods prevail.

Another thing to look out for while steelhead fishing in Crooked Creek during winter is ice. Crooked Creek can freeze over completely, making it difficult or impossible to fish.

The conditions might not always be favorable, but when combined with a little knowledge about what areas will provide better odds than others (upstream or downstream), there are plenty more reasons why people should consider heading out into nature once things cool down.

Spring Steelhead On Crooked Creek

The spring season is a great time to fish for steelhead in Crooked Creek. The water levels rise from melting ice, drawing in more aggressive fish,

As the water warms, the Steelheads move into the faster-moving parts of the creek, making it easier to catch them. However, be aware that as the water warms and the ice begins to melt, this can cause decreased visibility in the water.

Focus on days when the water levels have dropped and are just starting to clear. This is often when large numbers of steelhead are caught.

In murkier water, fish larger, brighter baits, but as the water clears, start using smaller baits with more natural colors like orange, peach, and light pink.

Methods for Crooked Creek Steelhead

There are also different methods for catching Steelhead, which can be used alone or in combination with each other to maximize your chances of success.

Float Fishing on Crooked Creek

Float fishing is a very popular method for catching steelhead on Crooked Creek. As Crooked Creek has less pressure than the surrounding fishing spots, float fishing is a great option, allowing the bait to drift nicely down the creek.

Flies, worms, spawn bags, and beads are great bait options and will help you get a bite while fishing for steelhead on Crooked Creek.

Spin Fishing on Crooked Creek

Spin fishing is an effective method and is widely used by anglers while fishing for steelhead on Crooked Creek.

Spin fishermen use this method because it’s often effective and easily adjustable depending on weather and location, methods can include float-fishing, casting lures, and bottom bouncing.

Lure Fishing on Crooked Creek

Using a lure such as a spinner or a spoon is a great fishing method on Crooked Creek. Just make sure you are taking note of the conditions of the water and adjusting your lure (color, size) accordingly to maximize your chance of a bite.

The Best Steelhead Lures For Crooked Creek

The spinner is one of the best steelhead lures to use. It can move fast and cover water quickly. This makes this lure perfect for searching through Crooked Creek for steelhead

A spoon, if used correctly, can be very effective when it comes to fishing for steelhead on Crooked Creek. Spoons are extremely versatile, easy to use, and can last a very long time, provided you don’t lose them.

If you want to fish on Crooked Creek during cooler fall days or into the winter, a jig is perfect for the colder water.

Jigs are good for holding steelheads that are laying low in the dropping temperature.

Steelhead Rules and Regulations for Crooked Creek

Aside from ensuring you do not fish in the designated nursery area or impose on posted property, you will likely require a fishing licence.

As required by the state of Pennsylvania, anyone over 16 must have a valid fishing license. Prices vary depending on the type of license. You can see the price list and how to buy here: Buy a Pennsylvania Fishing License (

Crooked Creek Fishing Spots

The mouth is a good spot for fishing fresh run or staging steelhead, but the bushy overgrowth surrounding the creek can be tricky to get to. You should expect to walk about a mile into the stream from parking your car, following the lakeshore and onto the beach to get to the mouth.

You must again be aware of the nursery waters, which are completely off-limits to anglers, although once you pass this area and up to Happy Valley Road, there are ample fishing spots and a good flow rate. Another thing you must be aware of while you hike to the creek is posted property, which Crooked Creek does have.

There is limited parking available at the access points but plenty of trails to follow, which will get you the right spots for fishing for steelhead on Crooked Creek.

Steelhead Fishing Reports For Crooked Creek

A variety of up-to-date information for Crooked Creek is provided in the following fishing reports.

Tight Lines,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *